PCappreciator

Yes, it returns even if not pinned. That's why I figured I might as well pin it and unpin the "legitimate" icon.

Cool, thanks I've attached the screenshot of what I was trying to describe. I clicked on the Chrome icon, but the icon to the right of it popped up instead.

I tried before, but I'm not sure to to upload one. :/

It kinda worked, but when I click the newly fixed icon the window comes up under a second icon that looks like the one I was trying to fix in the first place.

I had a problem with Chrome so I re installed it, and the taskbar was duplicating the icons at first (two Chrome icons showed up, one with the active window that looked like the leftmost in the screeenshot and the other one doing nothing that looked like a normal icon should). I unpinned both and started the program from the Start menu and pinned the icon again, thus solving that problem. However, the icon (the leftmost in the screenshot) still looks really weird. It's just Chrome doing it, the other programs are fine. I tried the fix from the "Desktop Icon Error" but it didn't work. It's not a serious problem at all (Chrome works perfectly fine) but it's been bugging me... Operating system:Windows 7 Home Premium (64 bit) Service Pack 1 System root: C:\Windows Available physical memory: 3932 MB CPU: Intel® Pentium® CPU B950 @ 2.10GHz Drive Info: C: 447.66 GB Internet Explorer: 11.0